[Beowulf] CPU Startup Combines CPU+DRAM‹And A Whole Bunch Of Crazy

Lux, Jim (337C) james.p.lux at jpl.nasa.gov
Mon Jan 23 12:58:11 PST 2012

On 1/23/12 12:50 PM, "Rayson Ho" <raysonlogin at gmail.com> wrote:

>On Mon, Jan 23, 2012 at 11:35 AM, Lux, Jim (337C)
><james.p.lux at jpl.nasa.gov> wrote:
>> The "processors in a sea of memory" model has been around for a while
>> (and, in fact, there were a lot of designs in the 80s, at the board if
>> the chip level: transputers, early hypercubes, etc.)  So this is
>> revisiting the architecture at a smaller level of integration.
>I remember 12-15 years ago I was reading quite a few papers published
>by the Berkeley Intelligent RAM (IRAM) Project:
>So 15 years later someone suddenly thinks that it is a good idea to
>ship IRAM systems to real customers?? :-D

Or maybe, all good ideas keep coming up again, and each time, it's refined
a bit, or there's another possible source of funding appearing.

Look at "solar power transmitted by microwaves from orbit" as an example.
That one has a 15-20 year cycle time.

You have an idea which is attractive.. You get some money to run it
forward, and then insurmountable problems crop up, discoverable only with
significant investment of time/money (>> 1 work month).  That puts the
idea to sleep for a while until either the reasons are forgotten, or
technology has advanced to the point where what might have been
unreasonable the previous time is reasonable now.

Certainly in the computing world, where 10-15 years is sufficient for many
orders of magnitude change in performance along many axes, it pays to
revisit things, since what may have been a good balance or trade back
then, isn't now.

And that's sort of the thrust of their white paper (justifying that now
the time is right), as well as staking their claim to a bunch of general
applications, few of which are uniquely enabled by their proposed


More information about the Beowulf mailing list