[Beowulf] Intel buys QLogic InfiniBand business

Mark Hahn hahn at mcmaster.ca
Mon Jan 30 07:04:53 PST 2012


>> out of curiosity, has anyone set up a head-to-head comparison
>> (two or more identical machines, both with a Qlogic and a Mellanox card of
>> the same vintage)?
>>
>> There was a bit of discussion of InfiniBand benchmarking in this thread
> and it seems it would be helpful to the casual readers like myself to have
> a few references to benchmarking toolkits and actual results.
>
> Most often reported results are gathered with either Netpipe from Ames or
> Intel MPI Benchmark (formerly known as Palas Benchmark) or OSU
> Micro-benchmarks.
>
> Searching the web produced a recent report from Swiss CSCS where a Mellanox
> ConnectX3 QDR HCA with a Mellanox switch is set against a Qlogic 7300 QDR
> HCA connected to a Qlogic switch.
> http://www.cscs.ch/fileadmin/user_upload/customers/cscs/Tech_Reports/Performance_Analysis_IB-QDR_final-2.pdf

as far as I can tell, this paper mainly says "a coalescing stack delivers
benchmark results showing a lot higher bandwidth and message rate than a
non-coalescing stack."  the comment on figure 8:

     To some extent, the environment variables mentioned before
     contribute to this outstanding result

which is remarkably droll.  I'm not sure how well coalescing works for real
applications.


More information about the Beowulf mailing list