Need comments about cluster file systems

hanzl at hanzl at
Thu Nov 14 14:30:18 PST 2002

> > using something like Coda or InterMezzo (for systems where
> > local disks are quicker than network card).
> Ahhh, you are looking for a Named Subsystem that claims to be a Cluster
> File System.  The key to good performance is not exceeding the semantic
> requirements of the application by too much, and the best systems are so
> transparent to the end user that they don't Need A Capitalized Name.
> Our cluster system, for example, uses a specialized whole-file-caching
> filesystem internally. ...

I am looking for any working opensource solution for persistent file
chaching. Please enlighten me if you know any. I looked hard, but I
might have missed something.

> > (For sure others will point you to PVFS, which IMHO makes sense only
> > if network card is quicker than local disk.)
> It's frustrating to hear people talk about how wonderful InterMezzo and
> Lustre _are_, and dismiss PVFS and GFS.  Software that is not quite
> finished is always better and faster than software that already
> exists.  It only loses speed and features when reality looms.
> Talk about vaporware and deployed systems in different categories unless
> you clearly use the future tense.

I quite like PVFS, but I think it does not solve the problem. AFAIK it
can get speed of NIC. I want the speed of local harddisk, which is
much bigger with my hardware. But again, I am ready for any

I do not know any details about GFS but I will be happy to learn them
if anybody tells me that it can give me what I want.

I did not say Coda or InterMezzo are great solutions. They are just
the only solution I found. Bad ones, yes. Coda is too big, InterMezzo
is not finished.

Another (very good for me) solution would be Caching NFS Client [GJB98]:

which is unmaintained I think.

So, alltogether, I know no working opensource solution for persistent
file cache working (at least reading) at (nearly) the speed of local
filesystem. I want to have it, thet's why post to this list. I would
be more than happy to hear that GFS or PVFS or ScyldXYZ project
unknown to me can do this. Please let me know.



More information about the Beowulf mailing list